Production of Presence is a passionate plea for a rethinking and a reshaping of the intellectual practice within the humanities.
Paperback , pages. Published December 11th by Stanford University Press first published To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
To ask other readers questions about Production of Presence , please sign up. Be the first to ask a question about Production of Presence. Lists with This Book. This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Jun 10, Brad rated it it was amazing Recommends it for: Taking a step back from his "Farewell to interpretation" stance, this is a fascinating exploration in part via Heidegger of what the dominance of Cartesian intellectual orientations may exclude from the analysis of cultural phenomena. Gumbrecht calls for the generation of concepts that would "allow us to point to what is irreversibly no Taking a step back from his "Farewell to interpretation" stance, this is a fascinating exploration in part via Heidegger of what the dominance of Cartesian intellectual orientations may exclude from the analysis of cultural phenomena.
Gumbrecht calls for the generation of concepts that would "allow us to point to what is irreversibly nonconceptual in our lives" and makes a case for three of his own: As an ethnographer engaged with what Gumbrecht calls presence effects I found some of his assertions at once overly cautious and ethereal.
Production of Presence: What Meaning Cannot Convey
Gumbrecht doesn't distinguish between different orders of publics, a move that helps articulate how the different materialities of media matter, for example between a reading public and a listening public occupying shared space. The intersubjective and the performative are in general impoverished in his work which leads him to characterize the relation between presence and meaning as volatile rather than often stabilized in practice, for example through ritual a concept he often invokes and the other ways that publics constituted through co-presence dampen such volatility through repetitive associations.
My objections, while more than cavils, do not detract from my overall enthusiasm for this beautifully written and richly generative work. Dec 05, Mj Harding rated it it was amazing. Grumbrecht takes you through his own intellectual development--his embracing and then movement away from meaning production hermeneutics and his movement towards a more holistic model that engages with and privileges what Gumbrecht calls "aesthetic experience" or epiphany, or presence. I enjoyed the opening segment where he laid out his own intellectual journey and I really appreciated the synopsis on the development of the hermeneutically-based epistemology that rules in the humanities, but I Grumbrecht takes you through his own intellectual development--his embracing and then movement away from meaning production hermeneutics and his movement towards a more holistic model that engages with and privileges what Gumbrecht calls "aesthetic experience" or epiphany, or presence.
I enjoyed the opening segment where he laid out his own intellectual journey and I really appreciated the synopsis on the development of the hermeneutically-based epistemology that rules in the humanities, but I was totally fist-pumping inside my head as I read the second to the last chapter where he explains how this marriage of meaning and presence functions pedagogically. The reading I did was fairly careful as the writing was careful --I need to read this book again and again--and while it may seem that Gumbrecht is contributing very little to the academic conversation on the futility or impossibility of meaning production, what he did say seemed at first like a feather, but later hit me like a ten ton weight Dec 11, Emm rated it liked it Shelves: I'm ambivalent about Gumbrecht.
I think the chapter entitled "Beyond Meaning But herein lies the most frustrating thing about this book: The rest of the book reads as sentimental wallowing.
It feels as if Gumbrecht has fallen prey to impulse male scholars have to "feminize" themselves and their disciplines, I'm ambivalent about Gumbrecht. It feels as if Gumbrecht has fallen prey to impulse male scholars have to "feminize" themselves and their disciplines, bemoaning their positions of entitlement and power for not being edgy enough. See Braidotti's "Nomadic Subjects" for more on this comment. The long and short of it: At times, Gumbrecht reads as a baby.
The Production of Presence: What Meaning cannot convey
But Ch 3 is worth a read. Nov 12, Jeremy rated it it was amazing Shelves: An important work exploring the alternatives to the Apollonian world of meaning in the experience of presence, integrating insights about the aesthetic life and intense, fully-lived human experience. It synthesizes many nascent threads in contemporary philosophy seeking to surpass the post-modern turn. It might not be a definitive work, but it advances the conversation.
Feb 10, Brian rated it liked it Recommends it for: People seriously interested in art, semiotics and the humanities in general. I often speculate to myself that the purpose of most contemporary philosophy is to redress damage done by earlier philosophizing. That seems to be the case with this book.
Frequently bought together
As the subtitle suggests, Gumbrecht addresses the shortcomings of our Cartesian legacy, which is obsessed with meaning and hermeneutics. This book is an early attempt to start a discussion of how theorists might talk about the presence of something, that part of it's being that exists beyond or before it is interpreted. His ar I often speculate to myself that the purpose of most contemporary philosophy is to redress damage done by earlier philosophizing.
- Find in a library : Production of presence : what meaning cannot convey.
- Citation Styles for "Production of presence : what meaning cannot convey".
- Production of Presence: What Meaning Cannot Convey by Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht.
- Antipsychiatry: Quackery Squared.
- Hlavní menu;
- Guia Didáctica del Swat en Procesos Hidrológicos y Calentamiento Global (Spanish Edition)?
- FAMINE AND COLONIAL RULE!
His arguments are nuanced and engaging if sometimes discouragingly dense , not to mention philosophically refreshing, but there are times when, despite all the nuance and complexity, the general thrust of his argument seems merely to be taking baby steps on a path long ago blazed by mystics and theologians, who deal with incarnation and silence. To his credit, Gumbrecht admits, toward the end of the book, that his thinking has much in common with certain religious thought and he even interacts with a recent theological movement known as radical orthodoxy and tentatively with some Buddhist principles.
Overall, I recognize much value in Gumbrecht's arguments in part because the religious wisdom toward which his thinking is moving will be better received in the academy if put forth by a secular mind and I foresee myself referring back to this work in future scholarly discussions of art. Jul 11, Whitney rated it it was amazing.
This book seems to summarize my own academic career so far. Brigham Young University, Meaning culture: San Francisco State University, a nice combination of both, at times: Does it always follow you wherever you go? Here's how to deal with the critical voice inside your head. Achieve more, create more, and experience more success and joy - while taking less action.
The Production of Presence: What Meaning cannot convey | Slovo a Smysl
Are you fed up with being taken for granted? Learn how to set boundaries, stand your ground, and inspire others' respect in the process! A simple, step-by-step blueprint for setting goals you'll actually achieve! Dowse Your Way to Psychic Power: The Ultimate Short-cut to Other Dimensions. Want to break free from the shackles of the old you?
This book offers a blueprint for tapping into the cosmic mind to achieve a purpose-filled life. A Philosophy of Nature. An Ordinary Dude's Guide to Meditation: Learn how to meditate easily - without the Your first step to enlightenment: Stanford University Press; 1 edition December 11, Language: Related Video Shorts 0 Upload your video. Try the Kindle edition and experience these great reading features: Share your thoughts with other customers. Write a customer review. There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later. One person found this helpful. I enjoyed this book a lot All great concepts which I continue to reflect two years after reading.
Some of the book seems to be more concerned about his own personal intellectual strugglesi. I found the book very interesting, a new point of view that questions our cultural worldview and language. The author knows his field and therefore has lots of academic references and examples. It is sometimes difficult for non- english speakers and for people outside philosophy or epistemology but it is worth reading it, not only for scholars, but also for people who want to know more about emotional experience.
Presence has become a hot topic among communications industry analysts and entrepreneurs. Persons outside of the arts and humanities academia but who aren't afraid to venture onto new ground should also consider reading this book. For further discussion, see my review at [ See all 4 reviews. Amazon Giveaway allows you to run promotional giveaways in order to create buzz, reward your audience, and attract new followers and customers. Learn more about Amazon Giveaway. What Meaning Cannot Convey. Set up a giveaway. Customers who viewed this item also viewed.
Time and Contemporary Culture Insurrections: Critical Studies in Religion, Politics, and Culture. What Happened in the Twentieth Century?: Towards a Critique of Extremist Reason. There's a problem loading this menu right now.
- The Nature of Marketing: Marketing to the Swarm as well as the Herd.